BMG To Take Action Regarding Black Artists' Historic Royalties

BMG

After completing the first stage of the review of its historic acquired recorded music catalogs regarding racial disadvantage of Black artists, BMG has identified that four of the 33 labels in its historically acquired catalogs show statistically significant differences between the royalties paid to Black and non-Black artists. 

BMG’s historically acquired recorded BMG acquired catalogs, dating back to the 1960s between 2008 and 2019, include recordings on 33 labels by 3,163 artists, of whom 1,010 (32%) are Black. The recorded catalogs feature 15 labels whose rosters include both Black and non-Black artists. Of those 15 labels, an examination of recorded royalty accounts showed that in the case of 11 of them, there was no evidence of racial disadvantage. Either 1) Black artists earned the same as non-Black artists, or 2) there was no statistically significant difference between Black and non-Black artists, or 3) Black artists earned slightly more than non-Black artists.

In the case of four labels, there was a statistically significant negative correlation between being Black and receiving lower recorded royalty rates, a difference ranging from 1.1 to 3.4 percentage points.

BMG CEO HARTWIG MASUCH said, “Since before the dawn of Rock ‘n’ Roll, virtually all Pop and Rock music has its roots in Black music. Yet music’s history books are littered with tales of discriminatory treatment of Black musicians. It is time for the music industry to address its past. Making good on our commitment to search for racial disadvantage in our historically acquired recorded catalogs has been an enormous and highly complex task. We have learned a lot, and there is still more to discover. We will act on this knowledge. We invite other labels to join us in this mission – to turn the promises and hopes of Blackout TUESDAY into action.”

Following presentation of the analysis to the BLACK MUSIC ACTION COALITION (BMAC), the U.S.-based advocacy organization formed to address systemic racism within the music business, BLACK MUSIC ACTION COALITION, Co-Chairs BINTA NIAMBI BROWN and WILLIE "PROPHET STIGGERS submitted a statement: “Gathering, understanding and sharing data describing historic inequities in the music business is a core activity of the BLACK MUSIC ACTION COALITION, which was formed to advocate for an end to structural and systemic inequality in the music business and broader society. We welcome this initiative by BMG and believe if all other labels were to follow suit, this could be a game-changer for Black artists throughout the industry. We cannot fix what is wrong if we do not investigate and hold ourselves accountable for whatever the results may be.
 
“BMAC looks forward to continuing to work with BMG and every other music industry participant to understand this information and recommend strategies and best practices to create a fair, just, and equitable industry that respects the humans, who are at its core. Black artists and creators must be paid fairly if we believe genuinely that Black life matters.”

Regarding the BMG project – analyzing thousands of artist royalty accounts and millions of lines of data – was led by COO BEN KATOVSKY. He said, “We stand by Black artists, and we recognize the pain many feel about their history. We acknowledge that the totality of the Black music experience cannot be captured in a numerical study. Still, we wanted to forensically address racial disadvantage in its most tangible form – the payments artists receive from their labels.

“This project has been a huge undertaking. Our focus was to establish if there were differences in royalty rates, which could only be explained by skin color. While difference is not necessarily evidence of bias, there were instances of differences that are significant enough that they warrant closer attention. We will follow this through to its conclusion.

“We have learned a lot about our historic acquired recorded catalogs during this study. We have found a number of both Black and non-Black artists with terms in contracts signed decades ago, which we feel are not appropriate. While these legacy contracts may have been entered into willingly, are fully legally enforceable, and we paid the previous owners full market value for them, we feel we can do better. We will shortly bring forward proposals designed to do just that.

“We are very aware that BMG currently accounts for less than 2% of the global recorded music market, and our catalog assembled over the past decade is in no way representative of Black music as a whole. No broader conclusions, therefore, can be drawn from this study. However, we have learned enough that we are convinced that if it were to be replicated across the industry as a whole, it could do much to progress the cause of racial justice in music.

“After sharing our findings with stakeholders including clients, lawyers, managers and industry organizations including the Black Music Action Coalition and Music Managers Forum UK, we are now inviting record labels large and small to undertake similar audits of their Black and non-Black music catalogs and/or assist in providing independent researchers and academics access to such information.”

BMG will shortly bring forward measures which will benefit the lowest-paid recording artists across all of its catalogs.

« see more Net News